- A new analysis found that highly engineered consumables could be just as habit-forming as cigarettes.
- Scientists found that these foods are designed to maximize pleasure and hasten the absorption of reinforcing ingredients.
- The habit-forming nature of these foods suggests they drive uncontrollable eating and hinder natural hunger cues.
- The researchers propose that ultraprocessed foods could be governed by regulations akin to those for tobacco products.
Currently, there is not a standardized description of UPFs. Many define them as products that contain ingredients you would not typically use in a personal cupboard, for instance stabilizers and additives.
Many professionals employ the NOVA food categorization to identify ultraprocessed foods. This describes foods that are “formulations of components, primarily of exclusive industrial use, typically made by a series of industrial techniques and processes.”
A recent review released by The Millbank Quarterly suggested that UPFs may be as addictive as cigarettes.
“It is my view with this study, as UPFs are deliberately designed to be incredibly tempting to most individuals,” stated a bariatric surgeon who was not involved in the study.
Data from last year estimates that over 73% of the food supply in the United States are highly processed.
“Tobacco and UPFs are not just whole foods but highly engineered delivery systems designed specifically to increase physical and mental reward and repeated intake,” noted the review’s scientists.
Can UPFs Habit-Forming?
The paper combined data from addiction, public health history, and nutrition in order to identify sensory and structural characteristics that enhance the addictive quality of both cigarettes and ultraprocessed foods.
“It’s not all people is ‘addicted’’ to such products, but for a significant portion, they trigger classic addiction-like patterns: strong cravings, loss of control, and persistent consumption even with negative health effects,” said a preventive cardiology dietitian.
“These foods are purposely formulated with processed carbohydrates, extra oils, sodium, and flavor enhancers to maximize reward and ongoing intake, and the industry uses persuasive advertising strategies, especially aimed at young people,” she stated.
The researchers examined five key areas:
- rapid absorption
- pleasure-based design, or creating products to be irresistibly good
- dose optimization
- widespread availability
- misleading changes, or “health washing”
They found that, like cigarettes, ultraprocessed foods are carefully calibrated to deliver the optimal amount of sugar.
“Refined carbohydrates trigger the feel-good chemical release through the a key neural pathway, whereas lipids achieve this through fat detection in the gut,” the researchers wrote.
“… Ultraprocessed foods with significant amounts of processed carbs and extra oils are some of the most strongly reinforcing substances in the modern diet. Notably this processed carb and fat mix is virtually absent in whole foods.”
How such products rapidly deliver “pleasure-inducing” substances to the brain makes them potentially addictive, in a comparable way to cigarettes.
The review stated that while tobacco are designed to provide nicotine quickly, UPFs are engineered to rapidly digest and absorb, as they typically have little to no dietary fiber. This makes it easier for the body to metabolize fat and sugar faster.
Authors also point out that ultraprocessed foods provide deliberate flavor bursts that fade quickly and textures that melt in your mouth. This collectively works to deliver increased pleasure signals and encourages individuals to consume additional amounts.
‘Wellness Branding’ in Tobacco, UPFs
According to the analysis, both the tobacco and processed food sectors have historically employed a tactic called “wellness branding.”
This refers to where products are advertised and altered to create an perception of less danger while preserving the essential of their qualities.
Health washing in the tobacco industry became popular in the mid-20th century with the advent of filter tips on smokes.
They were sold as safety features that would trap harmful substances before they reached the respiratory system. In reality, these tips provide little significant benefit.
Yet, people typically adapted by inhaling deeper or smoking more frequently, which negated any reduction in harmful intake.
Food manufacturers has adopted a similar strategy. It employs packaging claims such as “low fat” or “no sugar added” to market ultraprocessed foods.
However, these foods still contain the very addictive ingredient combinations. The issue is that these changes present a superficial appearance of health while the item’s habit-forming nature and health risks remain intact.
Should Ultraprocessed Foods Be Regulated?
The researchers noted at the conclusion of their paper that food and smoking products are not the same thing.
Nevertheless, they cautioned that some UPFs function like engineered products rather than real nourishment. They proposed that public health policy should reflect this distinction.
“Tobacco offers a warning, and tobacco control provides a model of hope,” the researchers stated.
Due to policies, smoking rates in the US have fallen and have “altered cultural views of tobacco and eroded confidence in the sector.”
“It is my opinion increased education about the harmful effects of ultra-processed foods is essential to lower general consumption and improve public health. The approaches used to curb tobacco consumption have been effective and may be a helpful blueprint for UPFs as well,” commented one expert.
“It is not my view ultraprocessed foods should be regulated exactly as tobacco, but they do warrant more robust, tobacco-inspired measures: advertising limits, obvious front-of-package labeling, stricter standards on wellness assertions, and limits in schools or hospitals,” added another dietitian.
The authors reminded people that lightly altered and whole foods have sustained human health for thousands of years.